Key points
  • Longer loan terms and balloon payments can lower monthly repayments but increase total borrowing costs on car loans.
  • ASIC found some sales practices prioritised loan uptake despite risks to consumers.
  • Borrowers who stretch loan terms may pay more interest and face a greater risk of negative equity.

"What can you afford for a month?"

It's one of the first questions at a lot of finance desks. And it's a clever one... because it flips the whole conversation. It stops being about what the car costs. It becomes about what you can stomach every month.

Right now, the answer is usually "less". The RBA has just lifted the cash rate to 4.85%, its fifth rise this year. Budgets are tight. So a lower repayment sounds like relief.

Sometimes it is. But sometimes it's exactly how an expensive loan gets sold.

Here's the thing about a monthly number. It's easy. You can hold it up against your pay in two seconds. The total cost of the loan is harder to see... and nobody is rushing to work it out for you.

How a repayment gets smaller

There are a few ways to shrink a monthly number. Stretch the term. Add a balloon. Or pick a loan built around both.

ASIC's June 2026 review of car loans looked at eight lenders. Loan terms ran from 12 to 84 months, so seven years is on the menu. In review, most lenders also offered balloon payments, which is a lump sum due at the end, usually bigger than a normal repayment.

ASIC also raised concerns about one lender's product design, including longer, bigger loans being rewarded with lower fees and lower interest rates. More borrowed, for longer, and it looks like a better deal.

What the push looked like

One of ASIC's case studies is worth knowing about. It looked at a guaranteed future value loan, which has a shorter term of 12 to 48 months and a mandatory balloon payment.

To get the guaranteed value at the end, you may need to stay under an agreed kilometre limit and keep the car in a condition the lender considers fair wear and tear.

ASIC said dealer training for this loan was aimed at introducing it on every eligible car, every time. Some modules treated customers who wanted to pay cash, wanted to pay the loan off whenever they liked, or wanted to drive without kilometre limits as opposition to overcome. 

ASIC found the lender was prioritising that loan over longer term loans without the feature, which apparently benefited lenders and dealers and raised the risk of consumer harm.

The lender agreed to make improvements, including removing and reviewing the training modules ASIC flagged.

To be fair, that kind of loan can suit some people. The problem ASIC pointed to was pushing it on everyone, whatever they actually needed.

At the dealership, this is often sold as a “guaranteed buyback”. It’s a trade-in price agreed upfront, in a pretty envelope. That amount is due at the end, whether you trade the car in or not.

To keep the car, you have to pay for it. And a guaranteed buyback is not guaranteed approval. If you want new finance after, you’re assessed on your situation at the time. So you hand it back and start again, or you refinance it and keep paying for the same car, possibly for years. 

In the market for a new car? The table below features car loans with some of the lowest and variable interest rates on the market.

Update resultsUpdate
LenderCar LoanInterest Rate Comparison Rate* Monthly Repayment Interest Type Vehicle Type Maximum Vehicle Age Ongoing Fee Upfront Fee Total Repayment Early Repayment Instant Approval Online Application TagsFeaturesLinkComparePromoted ProductDisclosure
6.19% p.a.
7.32% p.a.
$583
Variable
New
$8
$400
$34,958
  • Available for purchase of new/demo vehicle
  • Get a personalised rate, won't impact your credit score
  • Borrow from $10k to $150k, 3 to 7 yr loan term
  • Unlimited additional repayments, flexible repayment options
Disclosure
5.67% p.a.
6.10% p.a.
$575
Fixed
New
$0
$350
$34,524
  • A leading Australian Finance Broker with proven experience you can trust
  • We've assisted more than 150,000 customers access over $8 billion in finance!
  • We are the experts at getting the keys in your hands
Disclosure
5.95% p.a.
5.95% p.a.
$579
Fixed
New
$0
$0
$34,757
  • No vehicle age limit
  • No ongoing or early exit fees
  • 1-7 years loan terms. Pay monthly, fortnightly, or weekly
Disclosure
6.99% p.a.
6.99% p.a.
$594
Fixed
New, Used
$0
$0
$35,634
Disclosure
Important Information and Comparison Rate Warning
Important Information and Comparison Rate Warning

The fees ride along too

A low repayment can also hide what's been added to the loan.

ASIC found consumers generally pay two establishment fees, one to the lender and one to whoever arranged the loan, like a broker or dealer.

Lender fees commonly sat between $299 and $995, and the fees for the broker or dealer between $912 and $1,500. ASIC also noted these costs are
often capitalised, which means they're added to the amount you borrow.

Read that as: you pay interest on the fees. Fees in that range can add up to a couple of thousand dollars, and the longer the term, the longer you pay interest on every one of them. The monthly figure won't tell you any of that.

Let's run the numbers

Take a $34,455 loan at 10%. Those are the median loan size and median interest rate for one lender in ASIC's review. These are my own calculations, with no fees included, so a real quote will look different. But the pattern holds.

Loan

Monthly repayment

Interest paid

Lump sum owing at the end

3 years, no balloon

about $1,112

about $5,570

$0

5 years, no balloon

about $732

about $9,470

$0

7 years, no balloon

about $572

about $13,590

$0

5 years, 30% balloon

about $599

about $11,800

about $10,340

Stretch a five year loan to seven years and your repayment drops by about $160 a month. It also costs you roughly $4,100 more in interest.

It's slower to pay down, too. After three years of repayments, you'd still owe about $22,550 on the seven year loan. On the five year loan, it's about $15,870. That's roughly $6,700 more still hanging over you.

Add a balloon instead (I've used 30% as an example, not an ASIC figure) and you save about $130 a month. Then you owe over $10,000 in one hit at the end, plus about $2,300 more interest along the way.

Nice monthly number. Bigger bill.

When a longer term or a balloon can make sense

I’m not saying a lower repayment is always wrong. It depends on the person.

A 7 year loan will always cost you more than a 5 year loan. That’s just the maths. But the lower
repayment can give you room when life moves... a new house, a new job, a holiday, Christmas.

Some lenders will let you take the 7 year term and pay it off in 5 with no penalty. Others add a fee. So ask before you sign.

Balloons can work in the right scenario. Think businesses depreciating assets, people with a high turnover of vehicles, or people who plan to upgrade in a few years and are happy to swap the car at the end and start again.

In my world, it’s mostly businesses and luxury cars, and usually on new or near new vehicles. Often your choice is a 5 to 7 year loan you pay off and own, or a balloon on a shorter term, or just a shorter term.

But if you can’t afford the car without the balloon, look a little deeper. Maybe the answer is something that fits your budget.

Start with the end in mind. When the balloon comes due, you can trade the car in and start again, upgrade with more finance, sell it to pay out the balloon, save the cash, or refinance it and keep paying. If your goal is to own the car, a balloon probably isn’t for you.

The car doesn't wait for you

There's one more catch with a longer loan, and it's about what the car is worth.

ASIC found the purchase price of financed cars was often significantly higher than the lender's own verified book value, and the average loan-to-value ratio at the lenders ranged from 94% to 127%.

That matters because if you sell the car later and the money doesn't cover the loan, you're left owing the difference.

Now put those two things together. A car loses value fast. A longer loan pays down slowly. So the stretch of time where you could owe more than the car is worth can last a lot longer. That's not an ASIC finding, it's just how the maths works.

What to ask before you sign

Don't just ask what the repayment is. Ask these:

  • What's the total I'll repay, including interest and fees? And what is it on a shorter term? Ask for the same loan quoted over three different terms, side by side.
  • What fees have been added to the loan, and who gets paid them?
  • Is there a balloon? How much is it, and what’s my plan for it at the end? If I want to keep the car, how do I pay it, and what if I can’t refinance? 
  • Are there conditions, like kilometre limits or wear and tear rules?
  • Can I pay the loan off early, and what does that cost me?

If the salesperson only wants to talk about the monthly figure, that's your cue to slow down.

Ask for the full figure

Your budget is real. Rates are up and money is tight, and I'm not here to tell you a lower repayment is always a trap.

But it should be a choice you make with the total cost in front of you... not one that gets made for you because the monthly number looks friendly.

Ask for the full figure. Ask for it in writing. And take the time you need.