Majority of Aussies don't want another round of super withdrawals

author-avatar By
on October 06, 2020
Majority of Aussies don't want another round of super withdrawals

Photo by Handy Wicaksono on Unsplash

With another round of emergency super withdrawal potentially being introduced, the majority of Australians aren't too keen on the idea.

The Assistant Minister for Superannuation, Financial Services and Financial Technology, Senator Jane Hume last night hinted at the possibility of another round of COVID-19 early super access on ABC's Q&A. 

"The vast majority of the correspondence I have to my office is actually asking for a third tranche of superannuation to be made available," Senator Hume said, after commenting on the success of the scheme. 

Senator Hume also defended the success of the scheme, denying that the government has shifted its responsibility to provide stimulus onto people by forcing them to dip into their superannuation savings. 

Need somewhere to store cash and earn interest? The table below features savings accounts with some of the highest non-introductory and introductory interest rates on the market.


4000$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]More details

Savings Account (Amounts < $24k)

    4000$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]More details

    High Interest Savings Account (< $250k)

      4001$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]More details

      Online Saver ($1-$100k)

        0500$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]More details

        Reward Saver

          000$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]$product[$field["value"]]More details

          BU Savings Account

            Rates based on a savings balance of $10,000. Sorted by total interest rates. Refer to providers' websites for bonus rate conditions and for any applicable fees and charges. Rates correct as of May 26, 2022. View disclaimer.

            The current second round of super withdrawals, initially introduced in March to help people cope with financial distress from the pandemic, ends at the conclusion of this calendar year. 

            A third tranche would be expected to start from January 1, and could potentially be announced as early as tonight's Federal Budget, although nothing is set in stone yet. 

            The Federal Opposition is expected to also oppose any possible further extension of the scheme, with Shadow Treasurer Jim Chalmers challenging Senator Hume's assertions on Q&A last night. 

            "Some people have no choice, Jane. They have had to turn to their superannuation in desperation," he said. 

            "The Minister for Superannuation spoke about early access as if it is something she's proud of, it is something that the Minister for Superannuation should be ashamed of, the fact that so much damage has been done to people's retirement incomes."

            But with the possibility of another super withdrawal round looming over Australians' heads, new research shows the majority of Australians don't want it. 

            A UMR poll revealed 70% of Australians want the early release scheme to come to an end as the economy enters the recovery stage, and Industry Super Australia (ISA), commenting on the research, said it would not support a third round due to the "poor targeting and the huge long-term costs of the scheme".

            ISA initially supported the scheme as a temporary measure to provide emergency funds to Australians, but has since changed its tune, saying many in Canberra have now come to view the scheme as a form of economic stimulus. 

            "With JobKeeper scaling back and JobSeeker’s future rate uncertain opening up super again would signal the government wants Australians to raid their retirement savings to substitute income support," an ISA report said. 

            "...with the economy beginning its march to recovery and the health crisis improving it is time to return super’s policy setting to its normal rules that the money is preserved until retirement.

            "The existing hardship provisions are a more appropriate mechanism to get funds to members who had fallen on hard times."

            ISA chief executive Bernie Dean meanwhile said the long-term cost of the scheme is now too great, and it must come to an end come December 31. 

            “Extending the raid on super will slug young Australians with a great big new tax to pay for a bloated future pension, drag down investment returns and will shove more Australians towards poverty in retirement," Mr Dean said. 

            “Workers should no longer be asked to sacrifice their future to prop up the economy now, there are other levers the government can pull to stimulate spending and get funds to people who need it.”

            Early super withdrawal: The numbers so far 

            The latest figures from the Australian Prudential Regulation Authority (APRA) released today show the total amount withdrawn from super funds across the country reached $33.8 billion by 27 September. 

            There have now been 4.5 million total applications after factoring in repeat applicants.

            Over the week to 27 September, 36,000 applications were received by funds of which 22,000 were initial applications and 14,000 were repeat applications. 

            The total value of payments made during the week was $267 million, indicating once again the scheme's popularity is slowing down after withdrawals peaked as high as $6.2 billion in the week to 12 July. 

            The scheme has continually come under heavy fire for a number of reasons in the last few months. 

            One report found four in 10 Aussies who withdrew super early experienced no drop in income, while another found 64% of the additional spending was on discretionary items such as clothing, furniture, restaurants, alcohol and gambling. 

            Although to its credit, 14% of the money was used to repay personal debts, especially credit card debts which fell massively over the pandemic months

            More criticisms of the scheme came from the fact that 395,000 people under the age of 35 had completely eroded their super balance to $0 by July

            More recently, it was revealed 50% either underestimated or didn’t estimate the impact of the withdrawal on their superannuation balance at retirement.

            As of the end of the June quarter, super contributions were negative overall for the first time since super was introduced. 

            Latest Articles

            William Jolly joined as a Financial Journalist in 2018, after spending two years at financial research firm Canstar. In William's articles, you're likely to find complex financial topics and products broken down into everyday language. He is deeply passionate about improving the financial literacy of Australians and providing them with resources on how to save money in their everyday lives.

            Be Savings smart.
            Subscribe for free money newsletters.

            By subscribing you agree
            to the Savings Privacy Policy